- Last Online7 hours ago
- GenderMale
- LocationVirginia
- JoinedJul 28, 2020
Also Available at
RSS Feeds
|
Jul 26, 2026
In light of the anime adaption released in 2026, I wanted to return to the manga adaptation of the light novel and see if it still held up to my glowing impression from 2023. The verdict is, it's complicated.
Within the scope of modern video game-based isekai stories, I still find the game mechanics used here to be immensely satisfying; Right alongside contemporaries like "Hell Mode" and "Shangri-la Frontier". The artwork is a delight, with expressive characters, beautiful scenery, and monster/character class designs cool enough to give you goosebumps. Power scaling in any action story is hard enough without the benefit of a leveling system to
...
help put things in perspective. However, I'll argue that stories that DO utilize game mechanics usually don't do so with nearly the level of inventiveness nor care shown off here. This was written by someone who loves RPGs and showing off broken builds, yet still mechanically sound enough to feel victories are earned. If you have any love for job-based RPGs like Final Fantasy V or Bravely Default, this will definitely tickle your fancy.
All this being said, after reading (and re-reading) this for the last 3 years, I'm starting to notice reused story beats. The story progresses in 14-page chapters and arcs that can last anywhere between 6-14 chapters. The vast majority of these arcs have revolved around the protagonist and/or his party fighting a vastly overleveled enemy ambush. Despite the life and death stakes of this world, our hero, Elymas, always seems to pull through without suffering major losses. You can argue that the dangers of this world and the risk that comes with being an adventurer has made most people desensitized to death, yet we see plenty of instances where they show cowardice when the possibility of it becomes more likely. With the way Elymas "plays" its hard to imagine someone hasn't called him out for his razor's edge, do-or-die fighting style. He's still 15 years old btw. Perhaps I'm being too harsh considering how frequently the story puts the party in the worst possible conditions. The battles are thrilling, don't get me wrong. However, the short page count, repeated cliffhangers, and long arcs are enough to make readers consider putting it on hold for a few months.
The world and its class system are so very interesting that I want to hear more about them, and see other characters on the team besides Elymas, and his first companion Luce, sporting broken builds. It's crazy to me that after 170 chapters, I still feel like we've barely scratched the surface of what this story can deliver. I may need to look into the light novel to see if they cover down-to-Earth character moments in greater detail than what we see in the manga. We still have moments like those here, but they're sometimes abbreviated in order to get to the next major battle. I'm hoping that the power-leveling takes a break in the not too distant future. If we get to see some new party builds, inner monologue exploring Elymas's risk taking (or at least his life before being isekaied), maybe even a gaiden story following one of the antagonists, I'd be down for it. But for now, the story reads like I'm eating a steak with a toothpick. I initially had this at a 9, purely due to being a manga that I looked forward to reading. Today, it's closer to a 7 with how long this is taking. It seems unfair to judge a story based on release schedule since it will have to end eventually. Even so, I'd like to be able to finish at least a few isekai stories while I'm still alive. And if I had to pick and choose, this would be one I'd prioritize.
tldr; The page count and chapter release frequency really hurts this otherwise interesting story. The isekai angle is threadbare. The world's inhabitants find using status menus and class systems from MMORPGs to be the norm. So someone from another world that plays it as a literal game, only serves to provide "hindsight" levels of cheating. The story thus far utilizes excessive use of disadvantageous monster encounters for shock value. Yet, the party still finds a way to pull through despite being so close to dying. It begins to desensitize not only the characters, but also the reader.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jun 18, 2026
Normally, rom/coms need some kind of hook to make them stand out amongst the sea of modern high school stories. Apart from taking place in a European setting with no magic, the 'twist" here is that our main character Maria, an outspoken tomboy and former heir to her family's martial arts, is now seeking a husband. The reason being, her parents have finally secured a male heir. After visiting her cousin Aida and attending a party, Maria is mistaken for Aida by her fiancé, and in true otome game villainess fashion, is publicly dumped in front of everyone. Despite the strong start, Everything that follows
...
is pretty bland by comparison.
Being an Isekai fan, I enjoy the occasional detour into something fantasy/romance/period piece? that doesn't focus on video game inspirations. However, unless the comedy portion has me cracking a few smiles at least, the romance had better be pulling the weight. Comedy to romance ratios tend to be all over the place with rom/coms. Here, it leans into the comedy more by way of Maria; It just isn't all that funny. I expected the anime to focus on Maria's training to become more lady-like, maybe throwing in a rebellion to be quelled in between (as the opening would falsely convince us to be the case). She beats up a few local bandits on her way home to announce her engagement, then a second time on her way back. Without spoiling anything, the whole affair feels like a filler arc.
Earlier I said "period piece" with a question mark because the story tends to be pretty loose with its references' authenticity. The way characters act in the presence of royalty would make you think you were at a modern day costume party, not an event to decide the future queen. It's hard for me to take the story seriously on points like lines of succession or damaged family reputation when the main character ignores all of that and everyone laughs and forgives her. The comedy undermines any seriousness rather than undercutting it which is what you should aim for in comedy that still wants the reader to care about people's problems. Otherwise, just crank up the comedy to 11 and throw in magic and demon lords. Hell, make a Dragon Quest reference where Maria saves the kidnapped prince from a Dragon instead of the other way around. A noble lady that excels at martial arts isn't even that big of a shock in today's mainstream when you think about it. Look at "May I Ask for One Final Thing?" just as an example. Long story short, the martial arts angle doesn't have much significance outside of showing the absurdity of a woman in gown and heels beating up bandits and drinking vegetable juice because haha, that's not what I expected. Thing is, I don't feel like laughing at something that should be taken as the norm by now; Both in modern standards and in mainstream entertainment.
The only compliment that I can offer is that the characters are drawn beautifully. Any scenes involving dances or Street Fighter uppercuts to the chin are well choreographed. The story itself just didn't have anything that grabbed me.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 19, 2026
I've recently been struck by a wave of nostalgia for a classic Shonen Jump story in Yu-Gi-Oh! and decided it would be a good idea to cross this early days adaptation off my bucket list. (Also because I'm struggling to find subbed episodes of the successor anime that focuses on card dueling). Since this was never officially localized, expect subtitles only and low visual quality. However, the age wasn't what bothered me about the anime. It was how it handled the adapting the source material.
For those out of the loop, Yu-Gi-Oh! began as a semi dark story for a Shonen manga, filled with games of
...
life and death in retribution of ne'er-do-wells. A high schooler (despite his size) completes an Egyptian puzzle that gives him a dark alter ego with expert level game skills. The series would eventually settle on a card game called Duel Monsters as the game of choice to be the face of the franchise. Prior to this, Yugi and his friends ran into scores of bullies, criminals, and various authority figures that abused their power. Not the least of which being Seto Kaiba. If we go by this description alone, then the anime is serviceable enough in covering Yugi's origins before the much better sequel anime. However, for those who know the manga and grew up with it like I did, this anime was disappointing. I fully understand that manga has a lot more freedom in its portrayal of things like blood, sexual content, violence, etc. But that doesn't mean I have to like it. Especially when both versions are being marketed to the same age group.
First off, the anime's visual quality is all over the place. In the episodes adapted from the manga, it's good enough, but for the anime originals it can get pretty bad. In one episode Anzu/Tea looked like she regressed in age by 3-4 years. Almost all of the games played by Dark Yugi have been shortened and/or altered to avoid leaving anyone dead or in some equivalent state to it. Watching the games that I remember from the manga just made me want to read the original all the more. Since the anime condensed so much content, the animation team couldn't be troubled to break anything into a two-parter to better explain the rules or make the games more exciting. One of the things I enjoyed the most in Dark Yugi's games was the victor's lecture about what it is they lack, right before dealing the decisive blow. It was a great way of imparting morals to the reader in case it wasn't obvious. Sadly I didn't see much of that here either. Sometimes, it's just about getting even. Now I'm not saying death is the answer to stupidity, but if you take away the irony of what led to their demise, at least make sure they come to learn the error of their ways. Some didn't.
Now for the characters. Hiroto/Tristen was originally a bully-turned-friend just as troublesome as Jounouchi/Joey. Now he's been given a makeover as a beautification club member with a personality similar to student council member. While I sympathize somewhat in the anime's attempt at giving him some originality as opposed to just being aggressive like Joey, but without any other notable skills. He still has Joey and Yugi's backs in a fight, but the vast majority of the show has him simping over his main love interest Miho. This girl technically appeared in the manga, but only once, and didn't have a prominent role. To be perfectly honest, she didn't need to be here. Miho as a character exemplifies some of the worst characteristics of a model teenage girl: materialistic, shallow, and manipulative of Hiroto's affections for the sake of getting something out of him. She also refers to herself in the 3rd person. Not a trait I associate with intelligence. While Miho is supportive on occasions, she mostly feels like a tag along to balance the group's hormone ratio and a comedy duo with Hiroto. There are other characters, mostly the ones employed by Kaiba for the sake of revenge, that are more misses than hits. Rather than exiting after their loss, two of them even come back near the end after clearly getting the boot from Kaiba after their losses. It was a really awkward revision to what should have been a highlight arc in the original story.
I think I've spoken enough, so let's wrap this up with a tldr; The anime has low quality visuals. It loses its fangs from the manga in a bid to be more TV viewer friendly and loses too much in the process of abridging the story and adding original content. The successor, Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Monsters, doesn't require you to watch this. It doesn't even acknowledge this anime. So you can watch Duel Monsters and assume that's where everything started and be none the wiser. If you must see Yu-Gi-Oh! before the card game took center stage, I implore you to read the manga.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 14, 2026
I ended up reading this completely on accident as a tag along to the end of the GX manga. It picks up immediately where we left off with Jaden's long awaited reunion duel. I was already salty since the main story was rushed AND ended before Jaden's last duel. I expected to see a round up of the cast, where they are now, how they're doing? You know, a proper conclusion. Nope. Not only do we just see (mostly) everyone just tuning in to watch Jaden's duel silently or else providing standard commentary, but the duel STILL doesn't finish! Just like the synopsis says, this
...
one-shot was meant to promote a structure deck which no one can likely buy anymore. Save yourself 30 or so extra pages and just skip this, assuming you even made it to the end of the main story.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 14, 2026
Yu-Gi-Oh! was a generational experience I was proud to have borne witness to. I greatly enjoyed the battles of the original manga/anime. The following GX anime was entertaining enough in its own right, but I didn't feel the bone chilling peril like I did when Yami Yugi was still the lead. After getting a nostalgia itch and hearing that the manga adaptation of GX was completely original, I sat back for a weekend hoping to enjoy a darker telling since manga adaptations have less red tape as opposed to anime. What I got was an 8/10 . . . until the second to last volume
...
when the narrative was rushed to completion.
First of all, I need to give credit to the mangaka for pacing the duels to fit a consistent chapter page count without deflating tension. I greatly enjoyed seeing everyone's duels, (again, prior to the last 2 rushed volumes). Almost everyone uses a deck that differs from the ones from the anime. Personalities are also different for some characters. Chazz in particular goes from being a snobbish Draco Malfoy elitist in the anime, to a levelheaded, focused duelist that effectively serves as a deuteragonist. But only slightly behind Jaden. Speaking of, unlike the anime, Jaden is given a powerful backstory in the manga and greater motivation to go pro than just dueling strong opponents and having fun.
The biggest failing comes from a climax that skims over the last 4 duels of the tournament arc, fast forwarding to the final blow so we can move on to the true antagonist. So many characters and their backstories were just passed over to wrap this up quick. It's like someone pulled the plug on funding. The final duel didn't even feel satisfying from a strategic level. Just a JRPG boss using their own busted cards and eventually losing to the powers of light and a little help from some supernatural bs. They could have put some kind of moral in there relating to letting old grudges go and moving forward to a better future. Especially since many of the duelists were focused on getting a grudge match with someone or other. But no, it just ended in a duel and everyone went back to their old lives like usual. I have to believe the end was more about selling the irl card game and promo cards than telling a great story.
Long rant aside, tldr: If you want to see the Chazz act like a Chad instead, sure, give it a read. Otherwise, this was only good for the promo cards.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Apr 4, 2026
So, as of this writing, I've officially finished reading the 2nd part of Ascendance of a Bookworm. MAL hasn't updated yet since each volume has an extra 0.5 chapter, so while it's hard to say an exact chapter count, there are 13 volumes. Naturally, since this is only part 2 of a 5 part manga adaptation of a light novel, it's strongly advised that you read part 1 first. With that out of the way, there isn't much else to say as far as reviews since my feelings in part 2 largely reflect part 1.
Myne is a rare character type in reincarnation isekai, being a
...
female protagonist that is NOT in fact an otome villainess. Her passion for books led to her rebirth in another world as a sickly commoner. The root cause of her sickness and drive to continue reading books would further entangle her in the machinations of shady business rivals and upper nobles trying to maintain the status quo. Myne's connections continue to grow, and with them, her understanding of the world and how it works (for better or worse). Her overzealous love for books provides great comedy between the drama and intrigue. With the understanding that you read or watched part 1, just know that Myne is not some warrior of light protagonist trekking across the world to slay a demon lord. Now that her vast magic capacity has caught the eye of the church, she will be expected to make contributions as is expected of nobles with magic. At the very least, we get to leave the city limits were she grew up and get to see the knight order in action. Though apart from some lite skirmishes, usually fueled by some amount of prejudice against commoners, they resolve relatively quickly. Part 2 is mostly about shedding more light on corruption, abuses of power, and Myne recognizing that in order to fulfill her dream of making books, she may need to put more than her own life at risk. While Myne was never a selfish person when it came to books to the point of sacrificing others' happiness for her own desires, her need for influential power will subsequently beholden her to take responsibilities for others less fortunate. Needless to say, she has a long road before she can enjoy reading books at her leisure.
The artwork is as beautifully expressive as part 1. If I hadn't watched ahead when the anime overtook the manga years ago, I'd have shed a few tears by the closing chapters. Multiple times I felt myself chewing my lip in frustration over Myne's seemingly unending struggles, but not because it was badly written. Quite the opposite. I'm as invested in the story now as I ever was. However, as with all multi-part stories, it's hard to truly review a story that isn't complete. If you enjoy the first part and want more, well boy do you get it here.
tldr; Reading part 1 is mandatory. Art remains the same as part 1 and is just as good. The manga covers slightly more material than the anime but both are still excellent viewing. No ecchi, no otome villainess, very original. Even some educational bits like how to make ink, paper, and stencils.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 27, 2026
Another season, another isekai. I've already tried pretty much every isekai available considered above average and next to none of them are finished. Despite promising myself that I wouldn't start any new ones, boredom won out and I decided to see if any of the less attractive looking ones at least had a better story. For a weekend binge session, It's not bad.
Getting the tropes out of the way, we have a former PC gamer enthusiast who gets conned into play testing a new hardcore RPG and unwittingly reincarnated into another world as a rare summoner class. The main character's second life had many tender
...
moments that did a great job of showing his emotional maturity and newfound value on family. Eventually he stops treating his new life like a game and starts aiming for the top, not as a play tester, but as a fighter genuinely seeking power enough to protect the ones he loves. Make no mistake, the artwork is butt ugly. I've seen Studio Deen anime that looks better than this. Fight scenes are no better, but I was more impressed with how the summoner abilities were utilized. The story doesn't feel original either. The best praise I can give it would be bargain bin Mushoku Tensei. That may raise some eyebrows, but I do see some similar story beats. The kid isn't an absolute perv, nor are there any ecchi scenes to speak of. Best of all, the summoner ability system actually sounds cool AND is presented in a way that makes sense to the viewer. Simple, but effective and not overwhelmingly powerful. Good enough that if this were an actual JRPG, I'd love to play it. By the end, our hero has a new goal to focus on and season 2 has been announced for July. I'll probably read ahead since this went from a 6 to a 7 by the last episode. But you REALLY need to be willing to look past the awful artwork and 3D monsters. It still falls into garbage tier isekai, but darn it it's at the top of the heap. This one's for the Isekai fans that need an order of fries before the heavy hitters return for their 4th season. And who doesn't love fries!?
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 26, 2026
Wow. This might be one of the harder animes to review. In the best interest of avoiding putting my foot in my mouth trying to write a detailed account, I'll try to be as concise as I can and pro/con this.
Pros: The animation is some of the best I've seen, right up there with Trigger and Ufotable. The enemies in particular are drawn as unsettling as Evangelion with battles similar to the movie Starship Troopers. Lots of blood, guts, dismemberment, decapitation, and even a few parts with self harm. The explosions and rail-gun shots fired in battle are a spectacle of every battle. Even the
...
conversations between characters outside of combat are as lively as a movie. OP music was okay. It sounds familiar from all the other anime of this type I've watched but thematically appropriate. The concept of heroes being used as penal workers is a nice twist on the betrayed hero trope. Another reviewer noted a parallel with Rising of the Shield Hero. While I wouldn't go as far as that, I can see where they're coming from. The hero Xylo gives off the appearance of a high school hooligan with his complete lack of respect for authority or honor. All the while showcasing his aptitude in adapting to tense situations and directing groups. The others respect his judgement and leadership, albeit begrudgingly in some cases.
Cons: The anime itself mostly serves as an introduction to the world, its primary cast, their summary backstories, and general hierarchy including factions both good and evil. That in itself isn't bad, but it leaves me wanting more by the end. Like I just finished watching a very long prologue. The characters themselves come across as a bit 2-dimensional. All you really need is to hear one exchange of words with any of the penal heroes and you've seen how they'll act through the entire anime. The goddess Teoritta in particular is one of the worst kinds of obnoxious Genki girls. It really clashes with the atmosphere to the point where you wonder if she wandered in from another anime. One would think PTSD might have changed their personalities even a little bit considering their occupations. I mentioned the guts and blood before. This is both a pro and a con seeing as this is a dark fantasy. Those faint of heart or have triggers to self harm should be weary. Also, those cool explosions are used pretty excessively in battles. Dare I say almost too much. I would have loved to see more elegant one-on-one fighting, but there's only so much you can do when almost every battle focuses on crowd control. Like I said, Starship Troopers. This last part has more to do with lack of knowledge of where the story is going. The reasoning behind convicts being sentenced to penal heroes sounds pretty flimsy for a few of them. I realize the church has a lot of pull here, but considering what the enemy is capable of, you'd think more people would question this decision. Especially in Xylo's case with him being a former knight with a strong resume. We'll have to see.
Conclusion: These 12 episodes went by in a flash, and I'm cautiously interested to see where this goes since we've only been given peeks. While the animation quality is an undeniable 10, however certain characters drag my overall score. There's still too much we don't know yet. I may retroactively rate this higher or lower depending on how the story is handled in future seasons. Dark fantasy is not for everyone, but this is still one of the best looking animes to watch this season.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 25, 2026
Writing this is difficult for me. Not because I'm conflicted about whether the anime is good or bad, it IS bad. But the manga is one of the more pleasant isekais I've enjoyed reading in the last few years. So rather than go over what makes the anime bad, I'd like to at least direct any potential inquirers' to the more entertaining adaptation, and why.
First off, Van is a banished noble due to having a seemingly useless ability to craft objects. This is largely due to the kingdom's emphasis on rearing powerful elemental spellcasters for the purposes of war. This bias view, combined with the
...
intricate thought process and large magic reserve necessary for a creation magic means Van as a reincarnator is one of the few best suited to abuse this. This banishment troupe and 'seemingly' useless skill setup is nothing new to the genre. However, I do like how the manga takes time to explain Van's thought process in making base components down to a molecular level, something the anime glosses over and the OP an ED themes play up as though this were a preschooler's cartoon.
The overall tone in the anime aims to be more lighthearted and comedic than the manga. Even going so far as to pad out the episode of the apkallu meeting into a sporting event for Van's arranged marriage. It wouldn't surprise me if this event was in the LN, but it hurts the pace. The manga IS still funny, but it doesn't shy away from showcasing darker moments. For example, the act of enslaving the local thieves that were chased by the herd of armored lizards was completely removed from the anime, as was the newly recruited slaves-turned-civilians bought from the capital after selling the dragon parts. While I'm not encouraging the practice of slavery, obviously, removing it was a missed opportunity to showcase Van's progressive thinking. We also miss out on colorful new recruits to Van's army whose battle scenes get severely truncated due to being rushed near the end. What should have happened in the first war battle was a glorious combination of Van's mobile ballista's shooting down enemy wyverns in the air while his adorable fiancé Arte attacks anything near ground level with her puppets which makes for an understandably devastating combo. What we GOT was just a handful of adventurers and Arte attacking for about a minute and a half before retreating. The nuance of why Van prefers to stay off the battlefield in answer to the king is also handled poorly, pretty much boiling down to "I don't want to get hurt". Whereas in the manga, he presents a logical argument as to why he can't afford to overextend what little troops he has due to the enemy's heavy reliance on aerial units. Something that none of the nobles seem to have countermeasures for. These last two points in particular, makes him look even more childish and selfish. At that point, why not just make him a brilliant native born child instead of isekai? One thing I disliked the most was how the king was portrayed in the anime. In the manga, he gives off a much more regal gaze with sharp eyes and a yearning for a return to his traveling days before ascending the throne. This is also downplayed in the anime, as was his youngest son visiting along with him. The funniest part of the anime (not haha funny) was actually the last episode when one of the adventurers notes the number of wyvern reinforcements the enemy called in was around 50. I paused the screen and noted over 120 which Arte took out with only two puppets and no anti-air weapons (yeah okay). Like I said, the end was rushed and none of the battles were great anyway, but I felt compelled to write this even if no one reads it due to spoilers. However, please do consider the manga at least.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 14, 2026
The final 17 chapters have been translated so I decided to wrap this up and give my perspective while I could still remember anything (I started reading this in 2024). Short answer, this story isn't worth the time it took to read.
Our main character has a seemingly useless skill and is left for dead in a dungeon where the spirit of a holy tree, Yuri, saves his life. What follows is a story not unlike the premise of History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi. An underdog that is given the training regimen (but also mystic tree girl power) to become a hero. The journey has him venture
...
across the planet trying to help Yuri find her other sisters and in the process, uncovering a shadowy plot by an organization bent on wiping out humanity. Sounds very shounen, and it is. Complete with hefty amounts of dramatic crying and screaming from one of Hiro Mashima's works. Except I never really felt the vibe it was trying to convey. The ending felt incredibly rushed, and the true villain's ultimate reveal, motive, and subsequent defeat, I would consider to be the most comically bad I've ever seen in an action/adventure manga. Battles in the climax of the story also start using heavy amounts of blood to the point where it might trigger some viewers with a history of self harm or "un-aliving" attempts. It's so bizarre considering the string of jokes and harem vibes that precedes it.
On the surface, this should have everything I could ever ask for in this genre: well drawn art, highly expressive characters (seriously, compared to the average isekai this was drawn very well!), a diverse cast, and even romantic subplot. It just doesn't come together. I'll give it props for at least giving and ending that doesn't leave any loose ends like History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi, and that sucker went on for over 500 chapters! But if you don't mind a cast of tropey harem girls mixed with shounen fights that look flashy but will quickly be forgotten, you could do worse than this. I just can't get over how bad the villain was. I'll keep my final review as mixed even though I still wouldn't recommend it to anyone over something like Rave Master.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|